Apr | 27 | 2008

The Three Types of Comments

Posted by Jimmy as Blog Tutorial

I have never known a blogger who did not value comments highly. In fact, the opposite is true. Every blogger that I know cannot hide his or his excitement over receiving even a single (legitimate) comment on a post. I am much the same way – I love getting comments, and why not? They are indicators that people are visiting my blog, are actually reading my posts, and are finding the posts interesting enough to comment.

In my effort to analyze comments and to find out how to get more of them, I came to realize that comments can be grouped into some general categories. Knowing what they are can be helpful in the sense that identifying which kinds of comments you want to get can lead you to specific measures to elicit these comments.

I think that there are three types of comments:

-comments that merely make a statement
-comments that ask questions
-trackbacks.

I favor the first two types of comments. These are written out by people and actually give you an idea on what they think about your post. I believe that they are the most useful for the blogger. One, they may contain outright suggestions that you can use to improve your posts. Two, they can give you ideas on future posts. Three, they can provide opportunities to make new friends and interact with other people. The last type of comment is still a good thing in my book – though you may not be getting anything from the trackback as you would from the two other types of comments, you still get acknowledged!

4 Responses

Nancy McCord
28|Apr|2008

Just last week on ProBlogger, I read a guest writer say that she deletes all negative comments. Wow, talk about sanitizing your readers. She stated that if you entered a negative comment on her blog, or, if she plainly didn’t like it, your comment got the chop.

Well, I simply don’t agree, I’m with you comments are a good thing even negative ones. I think that comments even negative ones are what blogs are about - interaction and open exchange. The very best blogs are ones that encourage that and put that ideal first.

On my own blog, I never pre-screen or moderate my comments. I will delete hate comments and profanity but typically those are not pointed at me, but are rather comment spam that got through the Askinet filter.

Negative comments can cause controversy and controversy can encourage others to write in and comment on the commenter. This exchange can build traffic and readership.

So comments are great and I like you, encourage them on my blogs and only delete spam.
Jimmy
30|Apr|2008

Wow - that IS harsh and can be counterproductive as well! I agree with you, Nancy, negative comments are part of blogging. We are all entitled to our opinions.
More Ways To Optimize Your Blog For Your Readers | Biziki
06|May|2008

[...] make it hard for readers to leave their comments. It is understandable that you would want to set certain measures in place in order to weed out [...]
BKOsOsuper
06|Dec|2008

Whether to find a theme which was not discussed on one on this a blog?And that we communicate only on blog themes, and other themes are not present.
Новый фильм бондарчука

Our Features

Design and Themes

Is Your Blog W3C Compliant?

Last night I checked my personal blog’s code hoping I can proudly display the W3C Validated Button. Since I use Blogger and do not really do anything to clean up the code (beyond adding Alt-tags to the images I embed) I wasn’t surprised at all to find that my blog contained lots of errors - [...]
Read on
More Design and Themes Features
Software and Widgets

Wordpress Plug-ins

If you blog using Wordpress and can’t do something that you want done like adding Sphere-related content at the end of your blog posts you might be surprised to find out that there are already plug-ins available that make it happen.
To find good Wordpress plug-ins all you need to do is search for “wordpress [...]
Read on
More Software and Widgets Features
Reviews

A Friend In Need

I’m helping out my friends from the UA&P - IShareHappiness Blog Team.
Whenever you feel pessimistic, angry, troubled, frustrated, and depressed – what have you – you need someone to talk to. Someone who could help you be more optimistic and help make you feel that there is hope. Sometimes it’s hard to talk to someone [...]
Read on
More Blog Reviews
Monetization

Is Pay Per Post Worth It?

I have written about pay per post in the past and I am not talking only about the platform going by that name – I am referring to the practice in general. My opinion has not really changed, I still think that it is alright to engage in pay per post practices as long [...]
Read on
More Monetization Features
Marketing and Search Optimization

Building your blog brand step by step

Building your blog’s brand does not need to be difficult. However, when it comes to branding you should always remember to exert effort to be consistent with the image you wish to portray or you’ll end up with confused, turned-off, and/or skeptical readers. Branding inconsistencies will make it obvious that the image you’re putting up [...]
Read on
More Marketing and SEO Features
Blog Resources