Are Link Trains the Chain Letters of the Blogging Age?

You’ve probably seen several versions of a link train meme going around the blogosphere. Whether it’s supposedly optimized for certain web applications (e.g. Alexa version 1 & version 2, Technorati, MyBlogLog, Bloglines) or requires some other qualifier (viraltags, your name in your domain name, tech sites only, feed URLs, Z-listers only!), this method of sharing the link juice has grown immensely popular. It’s like a new class of memes have replaced all those generators and quizzes we love trying out.

If you look more closely, link trains are more like chain letters—stripped of hexes and a set number of people to send them to. But are they also hoaxes?

(Chain letters are nothing but empty threats, in case you haven’t figured it out yet!)

What is a link train?

A link train has the following parts: an operator’s manual (how the link train works), the main train (the links), and your own train (the links you’re going to add). It’s basically a list of links that grows as it from blog to blog.

Can non-blogs ride the link train?

Some trains probably allow it, but the reason link trains are popular is because they spread through blog posts. Websites that don’t update in a blog-like format probably don’t have a space for pasting memes, right? Also, the webapps mentioned above cater primarily to blogs.

Do link trains work? (Or, why do they work?)

It depends on your standards. One the one hand, link trains try to game the system (webapps and search engines) by demanding that one must keep all previous links (remember the main train?) and link back to them. (Some trains require you to also add them to your Technorati favorites, for example.)

On the other hand, it’s viral. You will want to jump on the train—whether you want to be more popular, or are just plain curious. Why?

  1. Easy. The instructions are extremely simple.
  2. Exciting. Imagine the rush of passing on something from blogger to blogger.
  3. Encompassing. Anybody can participate.
  4. Rewarding. Everybody on the train links and gets linked to you. You are helping other bloggers and they help you. (Take it to the next level by posting this Charity Link Meme!)

Hoax, Hex, or Hackery?

So, are link trains as useless as chain letters? Remember these points whenever a new link train shows up:

A link train are seen as a hoax by search engine optimization experts. Some trains aren’t SEO-friendly and the whole idea is a bit unnatural. Keep all of these in mind.

  1. Are the links keyword-rich, and in line with the content of your blog? Example: Viralinks uses asterisks (*) as link text.
  2. Link trains can even be considered as spam or even link farms—and can therefore be penalized by Google!
  3. Most people don’t mind since they still bring traffic, but if the train grows too long, will it still work?

A link train is not a hex, but bloggers can become highly dependent on it. If you don’t wish to link to certain sites on a link train, or you don’t think it’s that effective, don’t force yourself. And be sure to update your blog with entries that are not link trains!

A link train is a good hack to discover new sites. With all the new ways of blog-surfing, do we really need another one? Yes—whether they are natural methods or not.

Link trains are much better than chain letters, that’s for sure!

Comments

  1. Actually they’re spam. I wrote about that in Technorati Spam: http://www.notesfromatooluser.com/2007/06/technorati_spam.html

    Remember the system you’re trying to game isn’t there for your benefit. Its there for the end users.

  2. You make it sound scary :P Good thing I’m not into memes or the like.

  3. Then that means you see chain letters as scary! :P

  4. Link trains are gold. Just like any other method there is always a group of people that either just want to find the loopholes to help their ranks, but at the same time they are there to bring those loopholes to light and help those ranking institutions fix their faults.

    Technorati faves wouldn’t even be known about if it wasn’t for this type of list by large amounts of people. Why do I say that? Look how easy it is to get into the Top 100. If you have a group of 25 people you can get to the Top 100 in a couple weeks.

    Believe me. The traffic from such endeavors is minimal, if given at all. These are quick rank fixes over a few months. Nothing more. They put you on the map and you do with that what you can to make a few bucks. If you visit your friends in these endeavors you will certainly benefit from that exposure, make new blog buddies, and in turn create a large group of regular readers.

    Ultimately it is proper post writing, good information, popular news, keyword density, and those evil text link requests that push you up the Google search ranks. Those lists? Not so much other than Page Rank. Page Rank is just a number. Finding good keywords to write about and niche in Google is way more important to drive traffic. Then getting linked using those keywords.

    The people that do this do post great information about these things. This information is missing in Google. Those that know that information is missing decide that they are going to write about it. Filling the search need.

    These lists are very MINIMAL in what kind of things they do for bloggers ranking wise. They will help you make friends and bring your blogs to light, but they really aren’t going to do a ton for you.

    Technorati is a completely flawed system anyways. Everything about it is easily gamed. Some people need a decent Technorati rank, but most don’t. IF anyone was actually using Technorati, it wouldn’t have been so easy to get on it. Before these lists I’d speculate that the #100 bog had been faved less than 50 times. 50 TIMES! Top 100 BLOGS IN THE WORLD? I don’t think so.

Trackbacks

  1. […] Tutorials asks if Link Trains are the Chain Letters of the Blogging Age? I’m not really into them – my approach is to invest your time into quality content and the […]

  2. […] Tutorials asks if Link Trains are the Chain Letters of the Blogging Age? I’m not really into them – my approach is to invest your time into quality content and the […]

  3. […] Tutorials asks if Link Trains are the Chain Letters of the Blogging Age? I’m not really into them – my approach is to invest your time into quality content and the […]

  4. […] BloggingI’ve wondered out loud about this before. Blog Tutorials, however, takes an extra step and writes whether or not Link Trains are the Chain Letter of the Blogging Age. […]

  5. […] Ia of Blog Tutorials lists a few reasons why Link Trains can be appealing to bloggers, including the plain fact that they can be rewarding. He says “You are helping other bloggers and they help you.” True. He wisely goes on, I should point out, to note the downsides as well, including the biggie: “Link trains can even be considered as spam or even link farms-and can therefore be penalized by Google!” […]

  6. […] Are Link Trains the Chain Letters of the Blogging Age? […]

  7. […] com qualquer um, sem se preocupar se o tópico do outro blog tem à ver com o seu, entra em “link trains” (trens de links), etc. etc. Acham que uma grande quantidade de links apontando para seu blog […]